Contact O'Dwyer's: 271 Madison Ave., #600, New York, NY 10016; Tel: 212/679-2471; Fax: 212/683-2750
 
ODWYERPR.COM > PR Commentary return to main page
Seitel
Fraser P. Seitel has been a communications consultant, author and teacher for 30 years. He may be reached directly at yusake @aol.com.

He is the author of the Prentice- Hall text The Practice of Public Relations, now in its ninth edition, and co-author of Idea Wise.


Order from Amazon.com

IdeaWise
Click to order

Aug. 19, 2005
PR HANDICAPPING THE JUDGE, T.O. AND THE SOLDIER'S MOM
 

It's been a hot summer for the practice of PR, from ex-con Martha Stewart's "Comeback Image Campaign" to ex-rebel Mick Jagger's "George Bush Damage Control."

But the summer's three most significant PR conundrums have yet to be resolved. Each involves sensitive elements of public opinion and complex strategies to win over public support.

Here's how the three have evolved thus far and how each is likely to be concluded in the months ahead.

1) Here Comes the Teflon Judge.

As the usual lefty suspects from People for the American Way to the Alliance for Justice (the whaaaaaaat?) mass to oppose the nomination of Supreme Court nominee John Roberts, the judge's supporters respond with a two-word refrain.

"Good luck."

Or, stated another two-word way, "fat chance."

Since the President nominated him, Roberts has done virtually everything right. Where failed former nominee Robert Bork snarled when attacked and barely successful former nominee Clarence Thomas whined when maligned, Judge Roberts has been cool as a cucumber.

In particular, his public relations strategy has been picture perfect.

  • As soon as he was nominated, he headed straight to the lion's den to visit all his enemies - Chucky Schumer, Teddy Kennedy, and all the other spoil sports ready to pounce on him.
  • Last week, when the Democrats' fangless attack dog Patrick Leahy labeled Roberts' elusive writings as "intent on reversing decades of policies on civil right, voting right, women's right, privacy, and access to justice," the judge didn't so much as acknowledge the senator's yammering.
  • Meanwhile, whenever the paparazzi snap his photo, Judge Roberts perpetually flashes the grin of a winner. Which he is certain soon to be.

PR Prediction: Judge Roberts is a shoe-in to be the next Supreme Court justice. Self-respecting liberals should save their powder for the President's next nominee, who, trust me, will be way more ideologically conservative, not to mention controversial.

2) T.O. Becoming a Turn Off.

With apologies to Randy Moss, Terrell Owens is the best pass catcher in the National Football League. With further apologies to Randy Moss, Owens is also the NFL's most obnoxious player. T.O. and his agent, the notorious Drew Rosenhaus, are the most despised duo this side of Bin Laden and Zarkawi.

On his agent's Texas Hold 'Em advice, Owens got himself booted from Philadelphia Eagles' training camp two weeks ago, primarily because the team refused to renegotiate his seven-year, $49 million contract. Rosenhaus gambled that for the best receiver in the league, the Eagles would fold like the Giants' secondary.

Guess again.

Philly held its ground, and last week, the damaged split end returned to camp, suffering a serious shortfall in positive PR.

  • First, Terrible Terrell bad mouthed beloved and unyielding Eagles Coach Andy Reid.
  • Then he characterized even more beloved Eagles quarterback Donavan McNabb as a "hypocrite."
  • Predictably, some of the fans who greeted the returning hero upon his return to camp did so with signs that read, "T.O. Has Got to Go."

Not to fear. The unchastened Owens directed a typically-modest message to the fans on his website, which read, "Terrell plans to reward you with a season for the ages. Where small men succumb, great men overcome!"

They also --- if they aren't careful about alienating the public - risk getting traded or worse.

Mega-arrogant agent Rosenhaus would be wise to advise his wayward client to cool it before he pushes Reid and the Eagles to the point of no return.

PR Prediction: Before training camp breaks, Owens will make the following vow to the world: "I have decided to no longer be a disruptive force to the team and, after the season, in return for what will be for me a super star season, I will look for the Eagles to 'do what's right' with my contract."

3) Stuck in His Craw-ford.

It hasn't exactly been the swellest vacation month for President Bush.

He has literally been held hostage by the media for not granting an audience to Cindy Sheehan, the aggrieved mother who pitched camp in Crawford right outside the President's Texas ranch.

By now, the arguments for and against Sheehan are well known.

  • On the one hand, say her critics, she is a half-loony, foul-mouthed, anti-Bush militant, who is being financed and promoted by Moveon.org and its PR arm, Fenton Communications.
  • On the other hand, Mrs. Sheehan's only son, Casey, was shot dead at the age of 24, five days after he arrived in Iraq, to fight an increasingly-unpopular war.

While the right wing has leapt to Bush's defense and ever-so-gingerly begun to trash Mrs. Sheehan, her friends and motives -- the President is clearly losing PR ground. [Sheehan returned with her sister to California on Aug. 19 to tend to her ailing mother. She promised to return to Crawford, if she can.]

At this point, Mrs. Sheehan's crusade is a Catch 22 for Bush. He can't possibly meet with her and open the door to all the other grieving mothers who crave a "second chance" to question the commander-in-chief. Nor can he afford to end his vacation early -- which would effectively cut off Mrs. Sheehan's media access -- because returning early to Washington would be a sign of Presidential concern and capitulation.

So the President has no choice now but to accept his new "neighbors" -- for worse or worse.

PR Prediction: Whatever one feels about Cindy Sheehan or those backing her, one thing is indisputable: Mrs. Sheehan has successfully become the "face" of the opposition to the Iraq war. In the process, she has materially damaged the President and the war effort.

 
Archive of PR Commentary
 
E-mail to a friend
Tell O'Dwyer's what you think
Responses should include your name and affiliation, which will be withheld at the writer's request. Commentaries on subject matter are welcome. Personal references are not allowed. O'Dwyer's reserves the right to cover any story it deems newsworthy.

Responses:
 
PR Honcho (8/19):
Sheehan has exposed Bush as callous, indifferent and tone deaf. That's why the right is running scared and Rove has unleashed Rush, Hannity, et al to attack this grieving mother who lost her son in a "noble cause" that Bush won't or can't define.

From the get-go, Bush's lifelong sense of entitlement has led him to believe he is some kind of royalty and the entire Sheehan affair has left no doubt he takes a "let them eat cake" view of anyone who isn't among the GOP's wealthy and privilaged.

You are right, Fraser, he will pay a huge price for his mishandling of Sheehan.


 

Editorial Contacts | Order O'Dwyer Publications | Site Map

Copyright © 1998-2020 J.R. O'Dwyer Company, Inc.
271 Madison Ave., #600, New York, NY 10016; Tel: 212/679-2471